Lumbar disc herniation is one of the most common causes of low back and leg pain in clinic. There are a lot of non-surgical therapeutic methods widely used in clinic for treating lumbar disc herniation. The author assessed the available systematic reviews of non-surgical methods in treating lumbar disc herniation which had been published in these years, and finally a total of 13 systematic reviews were retrieved including 1 about conservative treatments, 8 Chinese medicine treatments, and 4 percutaneous treatments, such as chemonucleolysis and epidural steroid injection. The results showed that the conservative treatments included injections, traction, physical therapy, bed rest, manipulation, medication, and acupuncture. But no evidence was found to show that any of the above treatments was clearly superior to others including no treatment for patients with lumbar disc herniation. The outcomes from some reviews showed that Chinese medicine treatments were safer and comprehensive treatment of traditional Chinese medicine was relatively effective compared with single treatment. Electro-acupuncture, compared with conventional therapy (bed rest, waist protection, pelvic traction, manual or physical therapy) and oral medications as well, was safe and effective in alleviating pain and improving overall function. Chinese medicinal fumigation combined with traction was more effective than single treatment. Percutaneous treatment of chemonucleolysis had much better short-term effectiveness. Percutaneous epidural steroid injection also had certain effects. To summarize, Chinese medicine and percutaneous treatments may be effective in treating lumbar disc herniation. However, more clinical trials are needed, since current evidence is of low quality.
ObjectiveTo evaluate the effect of nickel-titanium three-dimensional memory alloy mesh combined with autologous bone for living model of canine tibial plateau collapse fracture by biomechanical testing. MethodsSixteen healthy 12-month-old Beagle dogs were randomly divided into 4 group, 4 dogs in each group. The dogs were used to establish the tibial plateau collapse fracture model in groups A, B, and C. Then, the nickel-titanium three-dimensional memory alloy mesh combined with autologous bone (the fibula cortical bone particles), the artificial bone (nano-hydroxyapatite), and autologous fibula cortical bone particles were implanted to repair the bone defects within 4 hours after modeling in groups A, B, and C, respectively; and the plate and screws were fixed outside the bone defects. The dogs were not treated in group D, as normal control. At 5 months after operation, all animals were sacrificed and the tibial specimens were harvested and observed visually. The destructive axial compression experiments were carried out by the biomechanical testing machine. The displacement and the maximum failure load were recorded and the axial stiffness was calculated. ResultsAll animals stayed alive after operation, and all incisions healed. After 1-3 days of operation, the animals could stand and move, and no obvious limb deformity was found. The articular surfaces of the tibial plateau specimens were completely smooth at 5 months after operation. No obvious articular surface collapse was observed. The displacement and maximum failure load of specimens in groups A and D were significantly higher than those in groups B and C (P<0.05). But no significant difference was found between groups A and D and between groups B and C (P>0.05). ConclusionThe nickel-titanium three-dimensional memory alloy mesh combined with autologous bone for subarticular bone defect of tibial plateau in dogs has good biomechanical properties at 5 months after operation, and has better axial stiffness when compared with the artificial bone and autologous bone graft.
ObjectiveTo evaluate the biomechanical effect of a nickel-titanium (Ni-Ti) three-dimensional memory alloy mesh in treating a canine tibial plateau collapse fracture model and to lay a foundation for further experiments in vivo.MethodsSixteen tibial plateau specimens of 8 adult Beagle dogs were harvested. Twelve specimens were taken to prepare canine tibial plateau collapse fracture models (Schatzker type Ⅲ) and randomly divided into groups A, B, and C, with 4 specimens in each group. Four normal tibia specimens were used as blank control group (group D). In groups A and B, the bone defects were repaired with Ni-Ti three-dimensional shape memory alloy mesh combined with autologous bone and simple autologous bone respectively, and fixed with the lateral plate and screw. In group C, the bone defect was directly fixed with the lateral plate and screw. By using a biomechanical tester, a progressive load (0-1 700 N) was loaded vertically above the femoral condyle. The maximum failure load was recorded and the stiffness was calculated according to the load-displacement curve.ResultsThe maximum failure loads in groups A, B, C, and D were (1 624.72±7.02), (1 506.57±3.37), (1 102.00±1.83), and (1 767.64±24.56) N, respectively; and the stiffnesses were (129.72±20.83), (96.54±27.05), (74.96±17.70), and (169.01±35.62) N/mm, respectively. The maximum failure load and stiffness in group A were significantly higher than those in groups B and C, but which were significantly lower than those in group D (P<0.05).ConclusionNi-Ti three-dimensional memory alloy mesh combined with autologous bone can repair the Schatzker type Ⅲ tibial plateau collapse fracture, which has better biomechanical properties than simple autologous bone grafting.
目的 評價股骨近端防旋髓內釘（PFNA）、動力髖螺釘（DHS）、伽馬釘治療股骨轉子間骨折的有效性和安全性。 方法 計算機檢索Cochrane圖書館（2011年第12期），PubMed （1966年－2011年12月），EMBASE（1974年－2011年12月），web of science（1958年－2011年12月），萬方數據庫（1992年－2011年12月），維普資訊網（1989年－2011年12月），中國期刊全文數據庫（1994年－2011年12月），中國生物醫學文獻數據庫（1978年－2011年12月），納入PFNA、DHS、伽馬釘治療股骨轉子間骨折的隨機前瞻性研究，采取修訂后的Jadad評分量表對納入研究進行質量評價。用RevMan 5.1軟件進行Meta分析。 結果 共納入12個研究（1 477例患者）。Meta分析結果顯示PFNA治療股骨轉子間骨折的手術時間[MD=?32.19，95%CI（?49.69，?14.69），P=0.000 3；MD=?4.52，95%CI（?5.24，?3.80），P＜0.000 01］，出血量[MD=?183.06，95%CI（?277.37，?88.74），P=0.000 1；MD=?49.49，95%CI（?84.15，?14.83），P=0.005]少于DHS組和伽馬釘組，但是三者在總有效率、住院時間和術后并發癥等方面差異無統計學意義。DHS組與伽馬釘組在所有指標差異均無統計學意義。 結論 與DHS、伽馬釘相比，PFNA可明顯縮短手術時間、降低術中出血量，但并不能提高總有效率、縮短住院時間以及減少術后并發癥；而DHS與伽馬釘治療股骨轉子間骨折的療效無明顯差異。